Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
If you’re a fan of homemade frozen treats, your Rival ice cream maker is the perfect tool to craft a wide variety of delicious, creamy desserts.
From indulgent chocolate to refreshing fruit flavors, the possibilities are endless.
Whether you’re looking to impress guests with a unique dessert or simply satisfy your sweet tooth, these 29+ Rival ice cream maker recipes will guide you through every twist, turn, and flavor sensation imaginable.
With these tried-and-true recipes, you can turn your kitchen into an ice cream parlor and enjoy decadent, made-from-scratch ice cream right at home!
29+ Delicious Rival Ice Cream Maker Recipes for Every Sweet Tooth]
Your Rival ice cream maker is the perfect companion for creating a world of endless flavors and textures.
With these 29+ recipes, you’ll be able to explore a variety of sweet and savory options that will satisfy all your dessert cravings.
From simple vanilla to more exotic flavors like rum raisin, there’s something for everyone.
So, grab your ice cream maker, gather your ingredients, and start churning your way to homemade perfection!
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
There’s a reason classic never goes out of style—Vanilla Bean Ice Cream made in your Rival ice cream maker is a smooth, fragrant delight that’s anything but plain.
The flecks of real vanilla bean swirl through a creamy base, offering a luxurious aroma and silky texture with each spoonful.
This versatile treat pairs effortlessly with warm pies, fresh fruit, or stands proudly on its own as a soothing dessert.
Strawberry Ice Cream
Bright, sweet, and bursting with summer flavor, Strawberry Ice Cream is a joy to churn in your Rival ice cream maker.
Juicy strawberries blend into a soft, pink cream with a vibrant aroma and just the right touch of tanginess.
It’s perfect beside shortcake, drizzled with chocolate, or enjoyed solo for a fruity finish to any meal.
Chocolate Ice Cream
Deep, dark, and indulgent—Chocolate Ice Cream crafted in a Rival ice cream maker delivers the ultimate cocoa experience.
Rich in flavor with a velvety, dense texture, it’s a sensory celebration of smooth chocolate with every bite.
Enjoy it with brownies, caramel sauces, or all by itself when you crave something satisfyingly bold.
Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Buttery, nutty, and undeniably comforting, Butter Pecan Ice Cream is a nostalgic favorite that your Rival ice cream maker brings to life with ease.
Toasted pecans folded into a buttery custard base create a beautiful crunch and warmth in every bite.
It’s a charming sidekick to apple pie or just the right amount of sweetness after a hearty dinner.
Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Cool, crisp, and refreshingly bold, Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream balances invigorating mint flavor with delightful bursts of semi-sweet chocolate.
The pale green hue and invigorating scent add to its appeal, creating a dessert that’s both calming and exhilarating.
It shines alongside rich chocolate cakes or stands tall as a palate-cleansing solo scoop.
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
A creamy dream speckled with cookie crumbles, Cookies and Cream Ice Cream made in your Rival ice cream maker is childhood nostalgia in every bite.
The crushed chocolate cookies soften into the vanilla base, creating a textural contrast that’s both chewy and creamy.
Serve it in cones, pair it with fudge sauce, or simply enjoy it straight from the bowl.
Peach Ice Cream
Soft, juicy peaches meet rich cream in this dreamy Peach Ice Cream that your Rival ice cream maker brings to life with ease.
Each bite bursts with mellow sweetness and a hint of tang, wrapped in a creamy, sunset-colored base.
Serve it with grilled desserts, fresh herbs, or enjoy it chilled on a quiet summer evening.
Coffee Ice Cream
Bold and velvety, Coffee Ice Cream is a caffeine-lover’s fantasy spun into a frozen treat.
The roasted aroma and creamy texture deliver a rich espresso kick balanced by a silky finish.
It’s perfect as a refined dessert on its own or alongside chocolate cakes and biscotti.
Banana Ice Cream
Smooth, mellow, and naturally sweet, Banana Ice Cream is a simple yet satisfying treat made effortlessly in your Rival ice cream maker.
Ripe bananas lend a creamy consistency and tropical aroma that melts on the tongue.
It pairs beautifully with nuts, caramel, or even a spoonful of peanut butter for a hearty twist.
Pistachio Ice Cream
Delicate, nutty, and tinged with a subtle earthiness, Pistachio Ice Cream is an elegant escape from the ordinary.
Its pale green hue and buttery crunch make every spoonful feel luxurious and refined.
Enjoy it as a stand-alone dessert or next to almond cookies and flaky pastries.
Coconut Ice Cream
Transport your senses to a breezy island with Coconut Ice Cream, a tropical delight full of flavor and texture.
Made in your Rival ice cream maker, this creamy dessert delivers a gentle coconut aroma and a rich, velvety base.
Top it with pineapple, mango, or toasted flakes for a refreshing finish to any meal.
Mango Ice Cream
Golden, juicy, and bursting with sun-kissed flavor, Mango Ice Cream is a tropical dream in frozen form.
Silky smooth and naturally sweet, this vibrant treat brings bold fruitiness to every bite.
It shines as a refreshing dessert on its own or served with sticky rice and fresh mint.
Blueberry Ice Cream
Sweet and slightly tart, Blueberry Ice Cream brings a burst of berry freshness to your Rival ice cream maker.
Its vibrant purple hue and juicy flavor make it both visually stunning and irresistibly fruity.
Enjoy it on its own, with lemon desserts, or as a colorful scoop beside waffles.
Oreo Ice Cream
Crunchy, creamy, and delightfully nostalgic, Oreo Ice Cream is a fan favorite that’s easy to whip up in your Rival machine.
Crushed Oreos swirl through a smooth vanilla base, delivering rich chocolate flavor with every bite.
Serve it in cones, pair it with brownies, or simply savor it by the spoonful.
Lemon Ice Cream
Zesty and refreshing, Lemon Ice Cream adds a citrusy brightness to your dessert lineup.
Its creamy texture is balanced with tart lemon notes that leave your palate clean and awakened.
Perfect as a summer palate cleanser or paired with blueberries and mint.
Cherry Ice Cream
Lush and velvety, Cherry Ice Cream is a sweet, ruby-red indulgence full of fruity charm.
Rival’s churning magic blends real cherries into a creamy base for a dessert that’s equal parts sweet and tangy.
It’s a perfect match for chocolate drizzle or a flaky tart crust.
Maple Ice Cream
Smooth, earthy, and naturally sweet, Maple Ice Cream brings cozy, autumn vibes into every scoop.
Its rich maple syrup base delivers warmth and complexity with a buttery mouthfeel.
Serve it with pecan pie, pancakes, or alone as a satisfying seasonal treat.
Avocado Ice Cream
Creamy, green, and delightfully unexpected, Avocado Ice Cream is a modern twist on indulgent simplicity.
Ripe avocados blend into a luscious base that’s rich in texture and subtly nutty in flavor.
It’s a hit on its own or elevated with lime zest, coconut, or a drizzle of honey.
Salted Caramel
Sweet, salty, and utterly addictive, Salted Caramel ice cream is a sophisticated treat you can easily whip up in your Rival ice cream maker.
The rich, buttery caramel base is perfectly complemented by a hint of sea salt that enhances every bite.
Enjoy it on its own or paired with brownies, apple pie, or warm cookies.
Raspberry Ice Cream
Tangy and sweet, Raspberry Ice Cream brings a refreshing burst of flavor to your dessert table.
Its vibrant red color and natural berry sweetness create a smooth, creamy texture with a hint of tartness.
Perfect for pairing with chocolate desserts or simply savored on its own during a hot summer day.
Mocha Ice Cream
For coffee and chocolate lovers alike, Mocha Ice Cream offers the perfect blend of bold espresso and rich cocoa.
The deep coffee flavor and creamy base create a luxurious, smooth treat that’s both energizing and indulgent.
It’s the perfect dessert to enjoy after dinner or with a warm slice of cake.
Tiramisu Ice Cream
Inspired by the classic Italian dessert, Tiramisu Ice Cream combines coffee-soaked ladyfingers with a creamy mascarpone base.
Rich, coffee-flavored swirls and a light, airy texture mimic the indulgence of the beloved tiramisu.
It’s a refined dessert to enjoy as a standalone treat or paired with a rich espresso.
Honeycomb Ice Cream
Crunchy, golden, and full of sweetness, Honeycomb Ice Cream brings a delightful texture to every bite.
The honeycomb pieces add a caramelized crunch, perfectly complementing the creamy vanilla base.
Serve it alongside fresh fruit, or indulge on its own for a sweet, satisfying treat.
Nutella Ice Cream
Rich, creamy, and full of hazelnut-chocolate goodness, Nutella Ice Cream is a decadent dessert that’s impossible to resist.
The smooth Nutella base delivers an irresistible sweetness, while its creamy texture melts beautifully in your mouth.
Perfect for topping with roasted nuts, drizzling with chocolate syrup, or enjoying straight from the bowl.
Pumpkin Ice Cream
Warm, spiced, and rich, Pumpkin Ice Cream captures the cozy flavors of fall in every creamy bite.
Cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove swirl through a smooth pumpkin base, delivering the essence of a spiced pie in frozen form.
Perfect for serving after Thanksgiving dinner or with a drizzle of caramel sauce.
Chocolate Mint
Cool and creamy, Chocolate Mint ice cream offers a refreshing balance of mint and rich cocoa.
The smooth minty base is complemented by chunks of dark chocolate, creating an indulgent yet refreshing dessert.
Enjoy it alongside chocolate desserts or on its own as a vibrant, cooling treat.
Butter Brickle
Caramelized and buttery, Butter Brickle ice cream combines crunchy toffee pieces with a rich, creamy base.
The toffee adds a satisfying crunch, while the buttery ice cream offers a smooth, luxurious finish.
It pairs beautifully with warm desserts or as a decadent treat by itself.
Key Lime
Tart, creamy, and refreshing, Key Lime ice cream perfectly captures the zest of fresh citrus.
The tangy lime flavor is softened by a smooth and rich ice cream base, creating the ideal balance of flavors.
Serve it with coconut cookies or enjoy it as a bright, refreshing end to any meal.
Rum Raisin
Bold and boozy, Rum Raisin ice cream combines plump raisins soaked in rum with a creamy, smooth base.
The rich rum flavor infuses the ice cream, offering a sweet, boozy kick with every bite.
Enjoy it as an after-dinner treat or alongside a slice of warm bread pudding.
Conclusion
Having a Rival ice cream maker opens up a world of dessert possibilities, and with over 29 recipes to choose from, you’re guaranteed to find a flavor that suits your mood and taste.
Whether you’re craving classic favorites or bold, new creations, this list will provide all the inspiration you need.
With just a little creativity and some quality ingredients, you can enjoy fresh, homemade ice cream anytime you like!
